Erik Karlsson to San Jose (2018)
Ottawa's September 2018 trade of captain Erik Karlsson to San Jose produced Tim Stuetzle (No. 3 overall, 2020), Josh Norris (later flipped for Dylan Cozens), Mads Sogaard, Leevi Merilainen and Zack Ostapchuk, while Karlsson himself moved again in an August 2023 three-team deal whose branches reached Buffalo (Konsta Helenius), Dallas, Montreal, Carolina, Detroit, Boston and Toronto.
Last reviewed Jul 3, 2026
- Erik KarlssonTwo-time Norris Trophy defenseman and Senators captain; re-signed with San Jose for 8 years x $11.5M AAV on 2019-06-17, which converted the conditional 2021 pick.Traded again by San Jose to Pittsburgh in the 2023-08-06 three-team deal.Traded again later in this tree
- Francis PerronProspect forward included with Karlsson; no further trade in this tree.
- Chris TierneyCenter; played out his Ottawa tenure and left as a free agent (no follow-up trade).
- Dylan DeMeloDefenseman.Flipped to Winnipeg at the 2020 deadline for a 2020 3rd (Leevi Merilainen).Traded again later in this tree
- Josh NorrisUnsigned 2017 first-round pick (rights only at the time). Became a core Ottawa center.Traded to Buffalo on 2025-03-07 in the Dylan Cozens deal.Traded again later in this tree
- Rudolfs BalcersProspect winger.Left Ottawa via a waiver claim by San Jose (waivers, not a trade).
- Conditional 1st-round pick, not lottery protected: 2019 if the Sharks missed the 2019 playoffs, otherwise 2020. San Jose made the 2019 playoffs, so it conveyed in 2020SJS 2020 1st, became No. 3 overall (won a 2020 lottery draw): Tim Stuetzle (C), selected by Ottawa.
- 2019 2nd-round pick, defined as the higher of San Jose's own or Florida's 2nd (both held by SJS). Conveyed as Florida's pick, No. 44 overall2019 2nd (No. 44 overall, originally FLA).Flipped by Ottawa to Carolina on 2019 draft day in a move up to No. 37 (Mads Sogaard).Traded again later in this tree
- Conditional 2021 2nd-round pick: conveyed if Karlsson re-signed with San Jose; would have upgraded to a 1st (not lottery protected) had SJS reached the 2019 Stanley Cup Final. Converted 2019-06-17 when Karlsson re-signedSJS 2021 2nd, No. 39 overall: Zack Ostapchuk (C), selected by Ottawa.Ostapchuk was later traded back to San Jose in the 2025 Zetterlund deal.Traded again later in this tree
- Conditional 1st-round pick no later than 2022, owed only if Karlsson appeared on an Eastern Conference roster/reserve list during 2018-19. Never conveyed; Karlsson stayed in San Jose
- Erik KarlssonReigning 2023 Norris Trophy winner. San Jose retained $1.5M of his $11.5M AAV (cap hit $10M in Pittsburgh, signed through 2026-27). Remains a Penguin as of 2026-07-02.
- Rem PitlickForward routed from Montreal to Pittsburgh.
- Dillon HamaliukProspect forward.
- San Jose's 2026 3rd-round pickLater chain: PIT to DET (2026-03-06, Soderblom), DET to STL the same day (Justin Faulk deal), then STL to TOR on 2026-06-27 in the Brandon Carlo trade; became No. 73 overall 2026, Zach Olsen (RW), selected by Toronto.Flipped by Pittsburgh to Detroit for Elmer Soderblom on 2026-03-06.Traded again later in this tree
- Mikael GranlundForward.Traded by San Jose to Dallas on 2025-02-01 with Cody Ceci for a 2025 1st and a conditional pick.Traded again later in this tree
- Jan RuttaDefenseman; no further trade traced in this tree.
- Mike HoffmanForward routed from Montreal to San Jose; no further trade traced in this tree.
- Pittsburgh's 2024 1st-round pick, top-10 protected (San Jose would receive it only if it fell outside the top ten). Converted when Pittsburgh did not win a 2024 lottery drawConveyed as No. 14 overall, 2024.Flipped by San Jose to Buffalo on 2024-06-27 (Buffalo selected Konsta Helenius at No. 14).Traded again later in this tree
- Jeff PetryDefenseman. Pittsburgh retained $1.56M (25%) of his salary in this deal.Traded by Montreal to Detroit on 2023-08-15.Traded again later in this tree
- Casey DeSmithGoaltender.Traded by Montreal to Vancouver on 2023-09-19.Traded again later in this tree
- Nathan LegareProspect forward.Traded by Montreal to New Jersey on 2024-03-11 for Arnaud Durandeau.Traded again later in this tree
- Pittsburgh's 2025 2nd-round pickBecame No. 41 overall, 2025.Swapped by Montreal to Carolina on 2025-06-28 (Carolina selected Semyon Frolov at No. 41).Traded again later in this tree
- San Jose's 2026 3rd-round pick (acquired in the 2023 Karlsson three-team trade)Detroit included it in the Justin Faulk trade with St. Louis the same day; St. Louis then sent it to Toronto on 2026-06-27 in the Brandon Carlo trade, and Toronto selected Zach Olsen (RW) at No. 73 overall in 2026.Passed DET to STL to TOR; became Zach Olsen, No. 73 overall, 2026.
- Elmer SoderblomForward.
- Mikael GranlundForward acquired in the 2023 Karlsson trade (tree asset).
- Cody CeciDefenseman. Not a Karlsson-tree asset; included for completeness.
- Dallas's 2025 1st-round pickNo. 30 overall, 2025: Joshua Ravensbergen (G), selected by San Jose.
- Conditional 2025 3rd-round pick that instead conveyed as Winnipeg's 2025 4th when Dallas failed to reach the 2025 Stanley Cup FinalNo. 124 overall, 2025 (originally WPG): Zack Sharp (D), selected by San Jose.
- 2024 1st, No. 14 overall (originally PIT, acquired in the 2023 Karlsson trade)Buffalo selected Konsta Helenius (C) at No. 14.
- 2024 2nd, No. 42 overall (originally NJD). Not a Karlsson-tree asset; included for completenessBuffalo selected Adam Kleber (D) at No. 42.
- 2024 1st, No. 11 overall (Buffalo's own)San Jose selected Sam Dickinson (D) at No. 11.
- Jeff PetryDefenseman acquired nine days earlier in the Karlsson three-team deal.
- Gustav LindstromDefenseman.
- Conditional 2025 4th-round pick: Montreal received the lower of Boston's or Detroit's 2025 4ths. Converted 2025-04-10, conveying as Detroit's 4thNo. 108 overall, 2025 (DET).Re-traded by Montreal to Boston on 2025-06-28; Boston flipped No. 108 to Tampa Bay for a 2026 4th, and Tampa Bay selected Benjamin Rautiainen (C) at No. 108.Traded again later in this tree
- 2025 3rd, No. 79 overall (originally VAN, acquired in the DeSmith trade; tree asset)Boston selected Cooper Simpson (LW) at No. 79.
- 2025 4th, No. 108 overall (originally DET, acquired in the Petry trade; tree asset)Boston flipped No. 108 to Tampa Bay for a 2026 4th; Tampa Bay selected Benjamin Rautiainen (C) at No. 108.
- 2025 3rd, No. 69 overall (Boston's own)Montreal selected Hayden Paupanekis (C) at No. 69.
- Casey DeSmithGoaltender acquired in the Karlsson three-team deal.
- Tanner PearsonForward.
- Vancouver's own 2025 3rd-round pickBecame No. 79 overall, 2025.Re-traded by Montreal to Boston on 2025-06-28 (with the Detroit 2025 4th from the Petry deal); Boston selected Cooper Simpson (LW) at No. 79.Traded again later in this tree
- Nathan LegareProspect forward acquired in the Karlsson three-team deal (tree asset).
- Arnaud DurandeauProspect winger; no further trade traced in this tree.
- 2025 2nd, No. 41 overall (originally PIT, acquired in the 2023 Karlsson three-team trade)Carolina selected Semyon Frolov (G) at No. 41.
- 2025 2nd, No. 49 overall. Not a Karlsson-tree asset; included for completeness
- 2025 2nd, No. 34 overall (originally CHI)Montreal selected Alexander Zharovsky (RW) at No. 34.
- 2025 6th, No. 189 overallMontreal selected Andrew MacNiel (D) at No. 189.
- Dylan DeMeloDefenseman acquired in the Karlsson trade; dealt at the 2020 deadline.
- Winnipeg's 2020 3rd-round pickNo. 71 overall, 2020: Leevi Merilainen (G), selected by Ottawa.
- Josh NorrisCenter originally acquired as an unsigned prospect in the 2018 Karlsson trade (tree asset).
- Jacob Bernard-DockerDefenseman. Not a Karlsson-tree asset; included for completeness.
- Dylan CozensCenter on a seven-year, $7.1M AAV contract at the time of the trade.
- Dennis GilbertDepth defenseman.
- Buffalo's own 2026 2nd-round pickEventually No. 60 overall, 2026: Alexander Bilecki (D), selected by Toronto after further moves.Flipped by Ottawa to Los Angeles on 2026-03-05 in the Warren Foegele trade, then by LA to Toronto on 2026-03-06 for Scott Laughton.Traded again later in this tree
- Buffalo's 2026 2nd-round pick (acquired in the Norris/Cozens trade, tree asset)LA flipped it to Toronto on 2026-03-06 for Scott Laughton, conditional on LA qualifying for the 2026 playoffs (converted 2026-04-13). Became No. 60 overall, 2026: Alexander Bilecki (D), selected by Toronto.Moved LA to Toronto in the Scott Laughton trade; Toronto used it on Alexander Bilecki at No. 60.
- Conditional 2026 3rd-round pick: Los Angeles received the better of Ottawa's or Washington's 2026 3rds (Ottawa held Washington's via the 2024 Chychrun trade). Converted 2026-04-13 when Washington was eliminated from playoff contention after Ottawa had qualifiedConveyed as Washington's 3rd, No. 80 overall, 2026: Blake Zielinski (C), selected by Los Angeles.
- Warren FoegeleWinger.
- Conditional 2026 3rd-round pick: Ottawa received the lesser of Dallas's or Los Angeles's 2026 3rds (LA held Dallas's via the Rantanen chain). Converted 2026-04-26 when Los Angeles was eliminated in the first round of the 2026 playoffsConveyed as Dallas's 3rd, No. 91 overall, 2026: Louis-Felix Bourque (RW), selected by Ottawa.
- 2019 2nd, No. 44 overall (originally FLA, acquired via San Jose in the Karlsson trade)Carolina selected Jamieson Rees (C) at No. 44.
- 2019 3rd, No. 83 overall (originally PIT). Not a Karlsson-tree asset; included for completeness2019 3rd (No. 83 overall, originally PIT).
- 2019 2nd, No. 37 overall (originally NYR, held by Carolina)Ottawa selected Mads Sogaard (G) at No. 37.
- Zack OstapchukDrafted by Ottawa at No. 39 in 2021 with the second-round pick from the Karlsson trade (tree asset).
- Noah GregorForward. Not a Karlsson-tree asset; included for completeness.
- Ottawa's own 2025 2nd-round pick. Not a Karlsson-tree asset; included for completenessNo. 53 overall, 2025: Cole McKinney (C), selected by San Jose.
- Fabian ZetterlundForward.
- Tristen RobinsProspect forward.
- San Jose's 2025 4th-round pickNo. 97 overall, 2025: Lucas Beckman (G), selected by Ottawa.
Scope rule: player assets and first-round picks that were re-traded get their own linked trade nodes; later-round pick hops beyond one flip are summarized in becameDescription (e.g. the SJS 2026 3rd passed PIT-DET-STL-TOR, with the final STL-TOR hop coming in the 2026-06-27 Brandon Carlo trade, and the BUF 2026 2nd passed OTT-LAK-TOR). Verified via live fetches on 2026-07-02: NHL.com trade articles, Wikipedia draft-page trade notes (raw wikitext downloaded for the 2019, 2020, 2021, 2024, 2025 and 2026 drafts), PuckPedia trade pages and ESPN. Retention: San Jose retained $1.5M of Karlsson's $11.5M AAV and Pittsburgh retained $1.56M (25%) of Petry's salary in the 2023 three-team deal, per ESPN; Montreal's additional retention on the 2023-08-15 Petry flip to Detroit was widely reported but not re-verified from a live source. Chris Tierney was never re-traded by Ottawa (departed as a free agent) and Rudolfs Balcers left Ottawa via a waiver claim by San Jose (waivers are not trades; claim date not re-verified this session). Francis Perron never became an NHL regular. The 2018 conditional 1st tied to Karlsson landing on an Eastern Conference roster in 2018-19 never conveyed. Karlsson remains a Penguin as of 2026-07-02; The Hockey News reported in the 2026 offseason that GM Kyle Dubas has no intention of trading him. Minor assets (Pitlick, Hamaliuk, Rutta, Hoffman, Gilbert, Robins, Pearson, Lindstrom, Durandeau) were not traced for further moves.
Sources
- https://www.nhl.com/news/san-jose-acquires-erik-karlsson-from-ottawa-300089330
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erik_Karlsson
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_NHL_entry_draft
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2021_NHL_entry_draft
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2019_NHL_entry_draft
- https://www.nhl.com/news/erik-karlsson-traded-to-pittsburgh-in-3-team-trade-345528364
- https://www.espn.com/nhl/story/_/id/38144636/erik-karlsson-penguins-3-team-trade-sharks-canadiens
- https://puckpedia.com/trade/728
- https://www.nhl.com/penguins/news/penguins-acquire-defenseman-erik-karlsson-from-the-san-jose-sharks-in--345527572
- https://thehockeynews.com/news/latest-news/nhl-rumor-roundup-penguins-not-moving-erik-karlsson-latest-red-wings-buzz
- https://www.tsn.ca/nhl/montreal-canadiens-trade-jeff-petry-to-detroit-red-wings-1.1996313
- https://www.cbssports.com/nhl/news/red-wings-acquire-jeff-petry-from-canadiens-in-exchange-for-draft-pick-gustav-lindstrom/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_NHL_entry_draft
- https://www.nhl.com/news/casey-desmith-traded-to-vancouver-by-montreal-for-tanner-pearson
- https://www.cbc.ca/sports/hockey/nhl/vancouver-canucks-montreal-canadiens-tanner-pearson-trade-sept-19-1.6972034
- https://www.prohockeyrumors.com/2024/03/devils-acquire-nathan-legare-from-canadiens.html
- https://thehockeynews.com/nhl/new-jersey-devils/latest-news/official-devils-acquire-nathan-legare-from-the-canadiens
- https://www.nhl.com/sabres/news/buffalo-sabres-san-jose-sharks-trade-nhl-draft
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2024_NHL_entry_draft
- https://www.nhl.com/sharks/news/sharks-acquire-a-2025-first-round-and-a-conditional-third-round-selection-from-dallas-in-exchange-for-mikael-granlund-cody-ceci
- https://www.nhl.com/news/dylan-cozens-traded-to-ottawa-senators-by-buffalo-sabres-for-josh-norris
- https://puckpedia.com/trade/957
- https://www.nhl.com/senators/news/senators-acquire-cozens-gilbert-from-sabres
- https://www.nhl.com/senators/news/senators-acquire-zetterlund-robins-from-sharks
- https://puckpedia.com/trade/973
- https://puckpedia.com/trade/1002
- https://www.nhl.com/senators/news/senators-acquire-winger-warren-foegele-from-los-angeles
- https://www.nhl.com/mapleleafs/news/maple-leafs-complete-trade-with-los-angeles
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2026_NHL_entry_draft
- https://www.nhl.com/penguins/news/penguins-acquire-forward-elmer-soderblom-from-the-detroit-red-wings-in-exchange-for-a-2026-third-round-draft-pick
- https://www.cbc.ca/sports/hockey/nhl/2026-nhl-draft-day-2-9.7251478
